think: Language and Self-Consciousness
Self-consciousness is widely discussed inside and outside of philosophy. It often finds linguistic expression in self-ascriptions of mental states such as "I think" and "I'm in pain". The philosophical discussion of self-consciousness is therefore intimately related to the understanding of utterances of this form. To a large extent, the debate is based on the cognitivist assumption that such self-ascriptions are autobiographical assertions whose content is identical with the semantic content of the sentences uttered. Expressivists in the tradition of Ryle and Wittgenstein, on the other hand, have claimed that such utterances are not expressions of second-order attitudes, of beliefs about one's thoughts or pains, but rather expressions of the thoughts or pains themselves. The aim of our research project is to provide a speech-act theoretical account of psychological expressivism and to explore the possibilities of expressivism also in relation to questions of first-person authority, self-knowledge, and self-consciousness.
- think1: Sprache und Selbstbewusstsein (2014) (Programme, Poster)
- think2: Repräsentationen des Ich (2015) (Programme, Poster)
- workshop with Dorit Bar-On: Neo-Expressivism (2016) (Poster)
- think3: Philosophy and the Semantics of "I" (2016) (Programme, Poster)
The project investigates the purportedly special epistemic status of I-thoughts. These are thoughts by which we represent self-related mental states, such as our own beliefs, desires, and feelings (e.g., "I believe that it is snowing" and "I am in pain"). The project
- examines the semantic structure and the epistemic character of I-thoughts,
- analyses selected psychological and neuroscientific studies that either support or cast into doubt this epistemic status, and
- reflects more generally on the scientific status and the methodological relevance of self-reports in psychological and neuroscientific research.
Principal investigator: Katharina Kraus
Doctoral student: Maik Niemeck
The research project is funded by the Eliteprogramme for Postdocs of the Baden-Württemberg Stiftung.